How is a church to pick a pastor? I was thinking about this question in preparation to preach 1 Samuel 9-10. So many people look to a man’s outward appearance or his public speaking abilities as the main criterion, but in 1 Samuel we see the dreadful consequences of judging a book incorrectly by its cover.
In 1 Samuel 8 Israel demands a king, “that we also may be like all the nations.†In chapters 9-10 God agrees to their demands and gave them a king, Saul, who turns out to be more like the kings of pagan nations then a king of Israel should have been. The biblical author describes Saul in the first two verses of chapter 9 as wealthy, tall and handsome. But then we get a description of his actions which are much more telling of his internal character and nature. When his father looses some donkeys Saul is charged with finding them. So off he goes wandering aimlessly all over the country side until he eventually gives up. His servant suggests that they visit the man of God in a nearby city, but Saul is concerned that he has nothing to pay the man of God. The servant is able to produce some money so off they go to see the man of God who is also known as a Seer. When they meet the man of God, it is Samuel the famous Judge over all Israel, but Saul does not know him.
What we have is a not-so-subtle biblical author telling us much about Saul, that I will summarize for you. (1) Saul is not a man with ideas for solving problems; note his aimless wandering in search of the donkeys. (2) Saul is not a man to finish a task; note that he gave up without success. (3) Saul is not a man to turn to God for help; it never occurred to him to seek the Lord’s help until his servant suggested it. (4) Saul does not know free unconditional grace, as he worries about having something to pay the man of God. And finally, (5) Saul is a man who does not know the Lord, as evidenced by his complete ignorance of Samuel the man of God who was leader over all Israel (note that Saul grew up in Gibeah, only a few miles from Samuel’s home in Mizpah).
So in this typical narrative fashion we get a wealth of information about Saul and by all accounts he is the wrong man for the job, though he looks that part (wealthy, tall and handsome). As soon as Israel is shown their new king they see his tall stature and shouted “Long live the king!†I fear that too many of us are too swift to proclaim, “Long live the king†as we elect a new pastor. May God give us the grace and wisdom to look past his nice suit for signs of a strong character and a heart for God, before we call him as pastor.